There are dozens of tools for running a sports club, and their price pages look alike until you read the fine print. This guide helps a board choose without a sales call. First count what your current process costs. Then understand the four pricing models. Then ask every vendor the same ten questions and compare the answers side by side. We do not name competitors here. The criteria matter more than any brand.
First, count what your spreadsheet costs today
Before you compare prices, put a number on the way you work now. A spreadsheet is free only on paper.
Take one month and write down:
- how many hours the board spends matching payments to players,
- how many messages go out asking “did we pay?”,
- how much time coaches spend retyping attendance,
- how many camp or tournament registrations arrived by text or e-mail and had to be copied over.
In a club of 200 players the total is usually a dozen hours or more a month. That is your reference point for every price you see below.
Four pricing models
Club software prices follow one of four models. Each behaves differently as your club grows.
Per-player fee. You pay a fixed amount for each active player, often with a monthly minimum. At 50 players it is small. At 400, the bill grows with the club. Ask whether “active” means active this month or everyone in the roster.
Tiers by roster size. Plans such as up to 50, up to 150, up to 500. The cost is predictable, but one extra player can move you into the next tier. Ask what happens in September when the new registrations arrive.
Percentage of payments. The software is free or cheap, and the vendor earns on every parent payment. Sometimes the parent pays the fee, sometimes the club. As an example, 2% of $100 in dues for 300 players is $600 a month that someone pays.
Free core, paid add-ons. The basic modules cost nothing with no roster limit, and specific extras cost money. The cost depends on whether you want the extras, not on the size of the club.
No model is wrong by default. Run the numbers for your roster two years from now, not today.
Ten questions for the vendor
1. Where does the parents’ money go?
The most important question. There are two designs. Either payments go to the club’s own account with a payment processor, or they go first to the vendor, who passes them on. In the second case the club waits for a payout and depends on the vendor’s financial health. Ask which processors are supported and whether your club already has an account with one.
2. Who pays the fees on a payment?
Processing fees always exist. The question is whether the vendor adds its own margin on top and who sees it on the bill: the club or the parent. If online payments are not available yet, ask for the date and what you do in the meantime.
3. How are sibling discounts calculated?
A percentage per player breaks with three kids or with siblings on different teams. Ask whether the billing unit is the family or the player. Ask to see an example with three children.
4. Does the coach have an attendance app?
Attendance taken by the coach supports reports to funders and conversations with parents about missed practices. Check whether the app works on a phone without an app store install, and whether a coach sees only their own teams.
5. Can a coach add players?
Many boards want only a few people to add names to the roster. Ask how the system separates the permissions of board members, coaches and parents.
6. Can a player be on two teams?
A kid plays on a travel team and a rec team, or in soccer and swimming. A system that allows one team per player forces you to create duplicate records.
7. How are camps and trips handled?
A camp means a deposit, a balance with a due date, a cap and a minimum. Ask whether sign-up and deposit tracking happen in one step and whether you can add your own questions to the form.
8. What about privacy and a data processing agreement?
A club holds information about children, so it needs to know how the vendor handles it. Ask where the servers are, whether each club’s data is isolated from the others, how consents are recorded and how a former player’s data is deleted. Ask for a data processing agreement and read it. Ask who can see sensitive details such as health notes. If your club operates in California or serves families abroad, privacy laws such as CCPA or GDPR may apply, and an attorney is the right person to say how.
9. How does migration work?
Ask whether the system will load your roster from a spreadsheet and whether anyone helps carry over family balances. Ask about the exit too: can you export everything to Excel if you ever switch?
10. Can I start without a contract or a credit card?
The best test is a week of real work with one team’s data. A 14 or 30-day trial is enough for a test, but not for a full season. Ask what happens to your data when the trial ends.
Red flags in a demo
A few signs that a product will cost you more than it saves:
- the demo uses only perfect data, with no siblings, no guests and no player on two teams,
- the answer to “where does the money go?” takes more than one sentence,
- exporting your own data requires a support ticket,
- the vendor sends automatic collection messages to parents by default and cannot turn that off,
- pricing depends on a call, with no public page.
A checklist before migration
When you have chosen, prepare your data in this order:
- Clean the sheet: one person per row, separate columns for first name, last name, birth date and team.
- Link siblings by a shared parent e-mail.
- Write down balances as of the switch date: who owes, who has a credit.
- Plan one message to parents with the portal link and the start date.
- For the first two weeks, count parent logins and first payments.
The step-by-step weekend plan is in moving from Google Sheets to club software. On the money side, read collecting club dues without spreadsheets and family discounts.
How it works in SportDesk
SportDesk uses the free core model. The roster, families, coach attendance app, dues, events with deposits, membership forms and e-mail to teams are in the Free plan, with no limit on players or time. The paid plans are Pro (club shop, SMS, e-mails without the SportDesk footer and priority support) and Pro AI (AI assistant), both coming soon outside Poland. E-mails in the Free plan carry a SportDesk footer. Card payments by parents are coming soon too, so for now you record payments by hand. Discounts are calculated by family, a player can be on several teams, and a coach sees only their own teams and does not add players. Each club’s data is isolated, and you accept a data processing agreement in the panel. You can export your data. Create your club, or see the pricing page.
Sources
- Pricing models and vendor questions are a framework, not statistics. Example amounts are illustrative.
- Privacy law references (CCPA, GDPR) are given only as pointers. Their application to your club depends on facts we do not know.
This is not legal advice. The product statements above reflect SportDesk as of November 3, 2026.